James 1:19-21

Is verse 20’s righteousness that which is imputed or the product of sanctification?

The only benefit I can see to considering the righteousness spoken of here to be imputed is that it is the righteousness “God requires.” God requires a perfect righteousness, which only He can give to us. It is not, however, incorrect to say that God requires a righteousness from His people that is not imputed but that is born out of a changed heart (see my posting on James 1:12-18 on trials for judgment). Jesus said, “For I tell you, unless your righteousness exceeds that of the scribes and Pharisees, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven (Matthew 5:20).”
Throughout scripture there are the righteous and the wicked. The righteous are those who have God’s perfect righteousness given to them by Him, but they are called “righteous” because of the way their actions have demonstrated their hearts before Him (James 2:23). A good New Testament illustration of this is Zechariah and Elizabeth. Luke 1:6 says, “They were both righteous before God, walking blamelessly in all the commandments and statutes of the Lord.” Their righteous life, although imperfect, corresponded to and developed out of a right standing with God.
The context of the chapter, and even the book, is a righteousness (such as Zechariah and Elizabeth had) that is worked out in the life of the believer. Verse 4 talks about being made perfect through steadfastness. James then corrects those who would accuse God for their sinful response to trials in verse13. In verse16-18 James warns believers that they should live a life consistent of being born of God. Chapter 2 deals with a faith that produces works. The context clearly requires that righteousness be understood as a product of sanctification. It is something observable, rather than the imputation of righteousness that precedes it.

Who or what is the object of the hearing, speaking, and anger?

The passage could mean “quick to hear [the Word], slow to speak [in defiance of the Word], and slow to be angry [at the Word].” In that case the righteousness of verse 20 would be personal. The advantage of this understanding is the immediate context. In verse 18 we are brought forth “by His word of truth.” In verse 21 we are to “receive the word with weakness.” In verse 22 we are to “be doers of the word.” Quick to hear can easily refer to the message of perseverance in trials that James brings. Slow to speak could then refer to the objection, “I am being tempted by God.”
The disadvantage of this understanding is that “slow to anger” fits very awkwardly in context. Obviously the Word of God makes people very angry. However, among those who might be nominal Christians with orthodox beliefs (see Ch.2) it is hard to conceive that they would become angry with the Word. Most people who are like James readers are very proud of the Word and proudly claim the sufficiency of Scripture. They do in reality despise the word, in that they will not conform to it (James 1:22), but it does not make them angry. See Romans 2:17-24.

The other possibility is that verse 19 means, “let every person be quick to hear [each other], slow to speak [to each other], and slow to [be angry with each other].” If this is true than the passage is parallel with 3:13-4:12, and righteousness refers to righteous fruit within a body of believers. When these passages are considered together it is obvious that this is the correct explanation.
In chapter 4 we learn that there are quarrels and fighting among the brethren. This corresponds to the anger, quick speaking, and slow hearing of chapter 1. The fighting in chapter 4 is a result of earthly desires (4:1-4) and earthly wisdom (3:15), which go hand in hand. This is parallel with chapter 1 where earthly riches tempt the brethren (see commentary on v.5-7) and they are show earthly wisdom (v.13).
In 3:16 James warns, “Where jealousy and selfish ambition exist there will be disorder and every vile practice.” “Disorder and every vile practice” corresponds to 1:21’s “filthiness and rampant wickedness.” In chapter 3 James exalts the wisdom that is from above. In 1:21 he commands his reader to receive the word, which is the source of such wisdom (Jeremiah 8:9).
The ultimate goal of these passages is that righteousness would be born in the lives of believers through a loving fellowship. “But the wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, open to reason, full of mercy and good fruits, impartial and sincere. And a harvest of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace (3:17,18).” “Know this, my beloved brothers: let every person be quick to hear, slow to speak, slow to anger, for the anger of man does not produce the righteousness that God requires (1:19,20).”

Review

Know this, my beloved brothers: let every person be quick to hear [what other’s have to say], slow to speak [considering his words carefully], slow to [have] anger [toward his brother]; [20] for the anger of man does not produce [among those in your fellowship] the righteousness that God requires [if He is going to give us the crown of life]. [21] Therefore put away all filthiness and rampant wickedness [which is friendship with the world] and receive with meekness the implanted word, which is able to save your souls [because faith that doesn’t produce works is a dead faith].